FREE ESSAY ON HISTORICAL CRITICISM OF MAN'S FATE

HISTORICAL CRITICISM OF MAN'S FATE

Man's Fate is a fictional story based on the 1927 Chinese revolution in Shanghai. The main
characters, Ch'en, Kyo, May, Katov, and Old Gisors represent different facets of
Malraux's belief system and personality.
The story opens where Ch'en is in the room of a sleeping man who he's about to
assassinate. The assassination of the businessman can be seen as the destruction of the
capitalism Malraux saw as the cause of the "oppressed and exploited Chinese" (Greenlee
59). Malraux came from a broken home and had great empathy for the working class. As
Ch'en is holding the dagger, he focuses on his victim's foot because he is about to
destroy a living thing. Ch'en is conflicted "…torn by anguish: he was sure of
himself, yet at the moment he could feel nothing but bewilderment [...]" (3). We can see
Malraux's own conflict here. In 1923, Malraux made a trip to Cambodia where he and his
wife, Clara, "...were arrested by the Surete [...] and charged with archaeological theft
[...] a moral failure that Malraux now at last recognized in himself" (Lebovics) 
Assassination and violence were a common occurrence in China during the revolutionary
years. The peasants were abused by the wealthy citizens and landowners, 
...it was from among their relatives and proteges that those who oppressed and lived off
the peasantry were recruited: the bailiffs and stewards who not only collected the rents
and debts due to their masters, but also took a substantial cut for their own benefit;
the tax-gatherers in whose registers the landlords' holdings were on an authorized
'special list', allowing them to pay taxes in inverse proportion to their wealth, or not
at all. (Chesneaux 81-82).
Malraux wants his readers to understand the reasons behind the revolt. Time and again,
Malraux draws vivid scenes of violence and deprivation. The meeting place to which Ch'en
flees after the assassination is that of a poor European shopkeeper, Hemmelrich. "At last
a squalid shop [...]" (11).
Kyo is the main character in the story; he is determined to do everything in his power to
lead the Shanghai revolt. 
"Kyo was one of the organizers of the insurrection, the Central Committee had confidence
in him." (14). Kyo wanted to see fairness for the proletariats. Likewise, Malraux was
involved in leftist politics. "Malraux jumped into leftist politics in the 1930s, landing
close to [...] the French Communists [...] visits to the Soviet Union, [...] and direct
involvement in the Spanish Civil War." (Lebovics).
The revolution is to take place very soon, the prelude of which is a general strike. This
is when Kyo and the other revolutionaries will make their move and attack the
authorities. "The city seems shaken by a violent storm, and the reader cannot help seeing
in the sudden outbreak of this cataclysm the uprising of the Shanghai people who, like
nature, are capable of fury" (Dye).
When Kyo arrives in Hankow he begins to realize the hopelessness of his belief that
communism will save them. "Was it possible that Hankow, the city to which the Communists
of the entire world were looking to save China, was on strike? [...] If Hankow was not
what everyone believed it was, all his people were already condemned to death. May too.
And himself" (139). By describing Hankow in such a way, Malraux shocks the reader into
seeing a vision of the revolution's outcome - the same outcome of the many French
uprisings which didn't significantly change the fate of the French proletariat.
Malraux reveals his insight into the events of the Shanghai insurrection, "Were Chiang
Kai-shek's troops waiting everywhere? Victors the month before, the Communists had known
their moves hour by hour; today they knew nothing, like those who had then been the
vanquished" (284).
For Chiang Kai-shek and the leaders of the Kuomintang it was possible [...] to dispense
with the support of popular forces [...] Indeed it became a necessity to dissociate from
such allies, whose activities threatened the position of the privileged classes in town
and countryside. The peasant upsurge, like that of the labour movement, objectively
contributed to the political polarization and the eventual explosion on the revolutionary
front which the Communists had been trying to prevent. At Shanghai on 12 April 1927
Chiang Kai-shek broke with the Communist Party and massacred thousands of militant
workers(Chesneaux 99).
In Hankow, Kyo meets with Vologin, the Russian leader in charge of Shanghai, to seek his
support. But Vologin tells Kyo that the comrades must give up their arms to Chiang
Kai-shek, even if it means their death. "You prefer to wait until Chiang has had our
people murdered?" (147). Kyo feels betrayed - the Shanghai revolt is a success and Moscow
wants them to give up their arms! (Moscow believes the Communists need Chiang Kai-shek in
order to keep the other Chinese warlords in check.)
The Communists "continued to treat Tchiang like a trustworthy revolutionary leader. [...]
they nevertheless left the militias and the whole Shangai labor force politically
unprepared for a possible attack from Tchiang. They were taken by surprise when he
attacked on the night of April 12." (Chesneaux, Barbier and Bergere 174)
By developing Kyo's character as a passionate leader who is concerned for the poor,
Malraux reflects a part of his own childhood. Malraux's writings
... stand principally as testimony to his efforts to overcome the disadvantages of his
childhood and establish a career in a profession normally reserved, in France, to the
more comfortable bourgeoisie. So ashamed was Malraux of his origins that it took Clara
Goldschmidt, his first wife, several months of marriage to learn of them ..." (Greenlee
13).
The character May is Kyo's wife and a German doctor. She's independent and sexually
liberated, strong, compassionate, and intelligent. "She was a doctor in one of the
Chinese hospitals [...] German, but born in Shanghai" (44). May tells Kyo about a sexual
encounter she had, "I finally yielded to Langlen and went to bed with him."(46) Although
Malraux portrays May as sexually liberated, he doesn't attribute the same sexual
liberation to his female Chinese characters. "[...] while sexual liberation is inherent
in Western feminism, most Chinese feminists in the 1920s still valued virginity and
chastity." (Li)
Malraux's confidence in Communism gives him a more liberalized perspective of women. One
of the tenets of Communism is feminism. "[...] gender issues played an important role in
the political culture of the early phase of the Chinese Communist Party [...] during the
early 1920s." (Levine).
As a matter of fact, Malraux's admiration for a strong and intelligent woman is evidenced
by his courtship with his wife Clara. "Malraux courted her successfully by, among other
little sweet things, telling her that she was the most brilliant person - after Max Jacob
- he had ever met." (Lebovics). 
Although Malraux understands the value of feminism, he also recognizes that Chinese women
were treated no better than chattel. Arranged marriages were a common practice. "[...]
the parents intervened directly in their children's marriage; they could betroth them at
a very early age to someone they would see for the first time on the day of their
wedding" (Langlois 105). After May returns from work at the Chinese hospital, she tells
Kyo "Always the same story you know. I've just left a kid of eighteen who tried to commit
suicide with a razor blade in her wedding palanquin. She was being forced to marry a
respectable brute" (44).
Malraux's whole political indoctrination comes from being raised in France. The attitude
of proletariat versus bourgeoisie is a long standing conflict within the French culture.
"The decade or so after 1902 has become known as the 'heroic age of syndicalism.'
Revolutionary syndicalists, in their emphasis on an immediate, face-to-face struggle
between workers and capitalists, continued the emphasis on daily confrontations, [...]"
(Haine 231).
Malraux depicts Old Gisors as an intellectual "[...] he found his room filled with white
flowers from the students [...]" (66), artist "His exquisitely pure sense of Chinese art,
of those bluish paintings on which his lamp cast only a dim light [...]" (67), and an
opium addict "He got up, opened the drawer of the low table where he kept his opium tray
[...]" (67). Malraux himself was an artist and a lover of art, he was also considered an
intellectual. In his later years, De Gaulle appointed him France's Minister of Cultural
Affairs. Malraux's depiction of Gisors as an opium addict was a popular literary theme of
the time and he has a clear understanding of how opium affects the user: 
At the time opium was in fashion [...] It is above all a literary theme, linked both to
decadence and to all that we connect with exoticism. To this drug is attributed all the
power of heightening perception and sharpening the mind. It is the opium of splendid
daydreams, of heightened knowledge of the world, of sharpened sensations, the opium which
consoles and puts right, the adventurer's companion. However, it is also the opium of the
poor, the terrible misery of destitution and dependence, a poison of degeneration and
suicide. It thus combines both the magic of sophistication and the intoxication of
abandonment." (Copin).
Malraux describes Gisors getting ready to take his daily measure of opium, no more than
five pellets a day. "His hands, which were preparing a new pellet, were trembling. Even
his love for Kyo did not free him from his total solitude. But if he could not escape
from himself into another being, he knew how to find relief: there was opium" (68). In
attributing opium addiction to Gisors, Malraux is again able to symbolically show the
reader the abuses of the Chinese people, the sense of hopelessness of their condition. 
Katov is a Russian communist and one of the organizers of the insurrection. He is the
quintessential existentialist. In the end, Katov gives the poison he saved for himself to
the other captured comrades, allowing them to avoid the unbearable torture and death by
fire that he will eventually suffer. He is a hero who demonstrates Malraux's:
...conviction that the best in man is inviolable [...] man's capacity to maintain his
dignity, in the teeth of life's degradations, humiliations and disfranchisements, so that
man's ever threatened and always dubious existence derives its ultimate meaning from his
ability to maintain his dignity for its own sake" (Langlois 161).
Bibliography
Chesneaux, Jean. Peasant Revolts in China: 1840-1949. Trans. C. A. Curwen. London: Thames
and Hudson, 1973.
---, Fran?oise Le Barbier, and Marie-Claire Bergere. China from the 1911 Revolution to
Liberation. Trans. Paul Auster and Lydia Davis, and Anne Destenay. New York: Pantheon
Books, 1977.
Copin, Henri. "La langoureuse Asie…the European view of Asia." Journal of European
Studies, March 1999 v29 i1 p5(1). Article A55207920. 22 March 2001
http://web5.infotrac-college.com.
Dye, Michel. "Andre Malraux and the temptation of the Orient in 'La Condition humaine'."
Journal of European Studies, March 1999 v29 i1 p45(9). Article A55207923. 22 March 2001
http://web5.infotrac-college.com.
Greenlee, James W. Malraux's Heroes and History. DeKalb: Northern Illinois University
Press, 1975.
Haine, W. Scott. The World of the Paris Cafe: Sociability among the French Working Class,
1789-1914. Baltimore and London: The Johns Hopkins University Press, 1996.
Langlois, Walter G., et al. Malraux Life & Work. Ed. Martine de Courcel. New York and
London: Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1976.
Lebovics, Herman. "Malraux's mission." The Wilson Quarterly, Wntr 1997 v21 n1 p78(10).
Article A19175974. 22 March 2001 http://web5.infotrac-college.com.
Levine, Marilyn A. "Review of Christina Kelley Gilmartin, Engendering The Chinese
Revolution: Radical Women, Communist Politics and Mass Movements in the 1920s," H-Asia,
H-Net Reviews, June 1997. 22 March 2001
http://www.h-net.msu.edu/reviews/showrev.cgi?path=22347867355238.
Li, Huey-li. "Engendering the Chinese Revolution: Radical Women, Communist Politics, and
Mass Movement in the 1920s." Philosophy East and West. July 1998 v48 n3 p517(3). Article
A21035588. 22 March 2001 http://web5.infotrac-college.com.